The mixed results from yesterday’s election resist instant analysis, but some things seem pretty clear. This post will probably strike many as being too positive—the election was certainly not the blue wave that we hoped for—but today I feel that the positive news is less known and understood than the many dangers, including Trump’s possible reelection, that we still face.
Trump is less powerful today than he was yesterday. This is the most important measurement of what happened yesterday.
He lost one branch of Congress, which means he will actually have to suffer some kind of oversight. Dennis Nunes and the other fawning, ring-kissing toadies in the GOP House will be replaced in January by smart, not-overly-civilized, partisan brawlers like Nancy Pelosi, Adam Schiff, and Jerry Nadler. The Republicans in Congress will no longer be able to avoid voting on issues that most voters actually care about.
Some of the coalition that won for Trump in 2016 went back under Democratic control. The upper Midwest (big Democratic wins in Michigan, Illinois, and Iowa) and Pennsylvania, which were critical to his 2016 victory, broke away from him. Suburban women really did turn against him, as predicted, and the Democrats made real gains among independents who gambled on Trump two years ago. Two-thirds of those confounding “swing” districts (districts that voted for Obama and Trump) returned to the Democratic fold. The Democrats won the vast majority of the 37 “split” districts that voted for a different party for President than for Congress. Virginia and Nevada seem much more blue today.
Taking back the House was a big deal. Democrats had to overcome a built-in, 7% gerrymandered advantage for the GOP nationwide to pull this off. That is insanely difficult. It looks as if the Democrats will win with a comfortable margin, too, having won about 35 additional seats. The Democrats will assume leadership over all House committees and the subpoena power that comes with it.
It would have taken a miracle for the Democrats to take back the Senate. That is not a rationalization, it’s just a fact. The Democrats faced the worst Senate roadmap imaginable: they had to defend 26 seats in a single election, and ten of those were in states won by Trump in 2016. The Senate has an even worse built-in advantage for Republicans than the House because a lightly populated rural states (aka Republican strongholds) get just as many Senators as blue states like California, which includes 37 million people. (Who are, by the way, just as American as North Dakotans. The Trumpists I know talk about the people who inhabit the East and West Coast as if they were a plague of locusts instead of citizens. “Thank god the Californians don’t run this country,” they say, when what they are actually saying is “Thank god the majority of Americans don’t run this show.” The Senate continues to solidify its position as America’s single biggest roadblock to progress.) And despite some brutal, heart-breaking losses, Democrats won Senate seats in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Montana, and West Virginia, which went for Trump in 2016. (FYI, the Senate roadmap in 2020 will be almost equally as bad for the GOP, which is important.)
Yesterday was oh-so-close to being a legitimate blue wave. I agree that the only thing that really counts in politics is whether you win or not, so this is definitely a blatant rationalization, but there were a slew of excruciatingly close races in Republican-controlled states in which the Dems came up short by just a few thousand votes. Cruz beat O’Rourke in Texas by 1.7%. Scott is beating Nelson in Florida by .4%. McSally is leading Sinema in Arizona by .9%. Kemp leads Abrams in Georgia by 1.6%. Gillum lost to DeSantis in Florida by .6%. These were losses that have the potential to crush Democratic souls, if only for their impact on redistricting after the 2020 census, but you can’t deny that there is a Democratic Party in Texas (and two new Democratic House members) this morning thanks to Beto O’Rourke.
American government looks more like America today—thanks to women. Women were the primary drivers of the Democratic takeover of the House yesterday. If you think that there needs to be less testosterone in American politics, yesterday represented progress. They started working on this the day after Trump was elected, and they continue to lead the resistance, and to lead it effectively. Women ran for office at record levels yesterday—the vast majority of them Democratic—and many won. In January there will be 100 women in the House for the first time. Two Muslim Democratic women and two Native American Democratic women were elected. Kansas elected its first woman governor. Four Democratic women elected to the House in Pennsylvania. Texas elected its first two Latinas to the House. And Colorado elected its first gay governor yesterday.
The Democrats are Dems were impressively disciplined in this election cycle. Instead of taking Trump’s bait on immigration, they focused on health care, which is not only the most important issue to Americans but also the issue on which the Republicans have literally no story as well as a horrific track record.
The way forward for the Democrats is to embrace progressivism. It’s an undebatable fact that the blue wave didn’t materialize in large part because Republicans ran up HUGE majorities in rural districts that couldn’t be overcome. And it’s true that the brilliant races run by killer progressive candidates like O’Rourke and Adams failed. But their progressivism made those races close, built up progressive campaign infrastructures in red states that will pay off further up the road, improved the Democratic bench, and, most importantly, forced the Democratic Party to actually stand for something in red states instead of continuing the truly dismal strategy of trying to camouflage themselves as something they are obviously not.
A lot of the GOP bad guys on the “most-wanted list” are out of a job today. Kris Kobach, whose only talent is keeping people from voting and who would have finished the destruction of Kansas begun by Sam Brownback, is headed to Fox News. Dean Heller in Nevada wrapped himself up in Trump’s robes but gave the Dems a pickup in the Senate. Scott Walker, the biggest union buster in recent history, was finally toppled in Wisconsin. Bruce Rauner, who wrecked Illinois’ credit rating, went down in flames. Congressman Dana Rohrabacher, who Kevin McCarthy thinks is on the Russian payroll, lost in California. A real pleasant shocker was the defeat in Texas of Pete Sessions, the incredibly powerful chairman of the House Rules Committee. Virginia Congressman Dave Brat, who complained last year that women voters were getting up in his grille, lost—to a woman, of course. Jason Lewis in Minnesota, another one of those right-wing talk-radio hosts, and who once said that single women are “ignorant of the important things in life” and actually complained about not being able to call women “sluts” was ousted by a female Democrat. Claudia Tenney in New York, who claimed that most mass shooters were Democrats, went down. Kim Davis, that county clerk in Kentucky who refused to grant gays marriage licenses, is looking for new opportunities this morning.
The pollsters were pretty accurate. Most predicted the Democratic takeover of the House and the continued GOP control of the Senate and very close gubernatorial races across the country.
The “booming” economy is mythic. The exit polling showed that 74% of the voters felt good about the economy, so most analysts are interpreting the Democratic gains as showing that a robust economy may not be enough to get Trump re-elected. I think that there is truth in this, but I also think that the pundits and the press are ignoring the reality that most Americans don’t feel that they are anywhere near out of the woods economically and don’t appreciate the GOP tax cut for the ultra-rich folks.
The Democrats don’t have to attack Trump directly to beat him in 2020. No Democrat will do a better job of inspiring voters who still care about things like morality, human decency, and leadership to turn against Trump than Trump himself. He will do that job for us. Trump will go down in history as the greatest progressive organizer since FDR. Debating policy, facts, morality, the Constitution, and the law with Trump is a complete waste of time. Fact checking and counting his lies will never defeat Trump.
The Democrats can use the House to define their message for 2020. I hope that Nancy Pelosi will be handing over the reins to a younger, more progressive Democrat before 2020 (supposedly there is such a deal), but the Democrats are lucky that they will have someone with her experience and negotiating savviness at the helm over the next year. The Democrats won’t get any legislation actually passed and signed off on by Trump over the next two years. I’ve heard many people today fantasizing about the amazing deals that could be made between Pelosi and Trump. This is laughingly delusional. Trump has shown repeatedly that his complete and total ignorance of both the legislative process and what is actually in any of the bills that have been debated or voted on since he became President makes him the worst dealmaker ever in the history of politics. As soon as the Republicans define their legislative goals, he attacks them on Twitter. As soon as his GOP Congressional leaders work a deal with the Democrats, he sabotages them. This will continue for the next two years. But the Democrats now have the opportunity to spend their first 100 days introducing a small number of big bills that actually outline a domestic program—for instance, shoring up the Affordable Care Act until 2020, raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, protecting voters rights and eliminating voter suppression, and re-committing to the environment. These bills won’t get passed, but they will force Republicans to actually vote on them and to establish a voting record that can be used against them. The first priorities should be bringing those bills to the House floor for a vote and preparing—thoroughly, in order to be successful—for the investigations into the mind-boggling corruption of Trump’s family, team and cabinet. Adam Schiff and Jerry Nadler are just the right kind of committee chairman to run those investigations. (As I write this Trump is clearly moving end the Mueller investigation, so the Democrats may have to fill the huge void that will be left.)
You can see a successful Democratic coalition taking shape. That coalition (which will have enough critical mass to win in 2020 but will assuredly not be anything like insurmountable) will be made up of women, minorities, gays, young people, seniors who worry about health care, and upscale suburban whites who like tax cuts but who also support gun control and the environment. (The environment could be a much bigger issue for the Democrats, given that the South is being particularly impact by it. I thought it would be a much bigger issue in Florida.) The Democrats could keep the House, take advantage of a much better map to win the Senate, and win the White House in 2020. Yesterday didn’t make that ultimate dream less of a reality.
Trump can be reelected in 2020. People forget that Trump won because of 35,000 votes cast in five states. Several of those states went Democratic yesterday, so his reelection prospects, which are still all too real, got a little harder. But he still has a slim path to victory, and he will stop short of nothing—and I mean nothing—to win in 2020. This is a man who sent troops to fight an imaginary foe in order to win the midterms. We haven’t seen anything yet.
Losing the Senate means that the GOP will continue to pack the courts with right-wing judges. This is another real, existential threat to the country because it is how the Trumpists could continue to run the country even if they lost Congress and the Presidency, and now they will have two more years to create a judiciary that will undo any legislation passed by a Democratic Congress and Presiden.
Medicaid expansion seems irreversible and unstoppable now. This is a big win for Americans, folks. Voters in the ultra-red states of Idaho, Utah, and Nebraska approved the expansion, and the voters of Maine now have a Democratic governor who will not veto the expansion they voted for. Something like 1.6 million more Americans will get affordable health insurance. The ACA changed the dialogue around health care, and now the Democrats can fully embrace “Medicare for all” and set the stage for a single-payer program.
Racism still works, but not everywhere. Trump’s campaigning for the midterms, which was conducted only in red, predominantly rural states, was an endless sewer stream of nothing but racism, and no one can now deny that the Republican Party is an out-in-the-open white supremacist party. So the biggest shock (even though by now it is no surprise) from yesterday’s results is how many Americans still vote support openly racist politicians, starting with our President. Steve King, who is an American Nazi, won reelection in Iowa. A Republican running for Congress in California who claims that the Holocaust never happened got 43,000 votes. A former leader of the American Nazi Party got 44,000 votes for Congress in Illinois. DeSantis ran a blatantly racist campaign in Florida and won. How else do you explain that a brilliant black candidate like Andrew Gillum lost in Florida, but that an incredibly bland, white candidate like Bill Nelson won in the same state? And the polls predicting solid margins for Gillum show that voters are still not telling the truth to pollsters when it comes to minority candidates. But racism seems to have backfired with non-rural voters and in more urban/suburban states. Bill Schuette in Michigan, Scott Walker in Wisconsin, and Scott Wagner in PA all ran anti-immigrant ads and lost. Racist ads didn’t work against Antonio Delgado and Sharice David. Anti-immigration hardliners Lou Baretta in Pennsylvania, Chris Kobach in Kansas, and Virginia’s Corey Stewart all lost and lost big.
It was one step forward and one step back for voting rights. Florida voters (almost unbelievably, given that Gillum lost) voted to restore voting rights to 1.5 million ex-felons. That’s nine percent of the voting-age population in that state. This was a huge win for Democrats yesterday. Voting rights were expanded by voters in Maryland, Nevada, and Michigan, but similar measures were defeated in Arkansas and North Carolina. And the loss of the governorships in Florida, Texas and probably Georgia will mean voter suppression will continue in those critical states. Importantly, however, anti-gerrymandering initiatives that took away redistricting decisions from the state legislatures in favor of independent redistricting commissions passed in Colorado, Michigan, and Utah. And the Democrats won control of the state houses in New York, Minnesota, New Hampshire, Colorado—big wins in terms of redistricting for 2020. But the loss of the governorships in Florida, Ohio, Iowa and probably Georgia mean that the Democrats will not be able to undo gerrymandering in those key states.
Millenials and minorities didn’t give Democrats the lift that the early voting indicated they would. The phenomenal spikes in young-voter participation in early voting in the end just meant that younger people were smarter about when to vote. In the end, the percentage of yesterday’s vote represented by millennials was 13%, a modest increase over the 11% in the last midterms. As far as minority turnout goes, African American voting was up 1% over 2014 and Hispanics were up 4%. All increases, but the Democrats still need to work harder to win these groups to make their theoretical winning coalition a reality.
The Green Party may cost the Democrats the Senate seat in Arizona. I can’t even discuss this rationally or comment on it without unleashing an avalanche of profanity. But if you think willfully stupid, woefully misinformed, or astonishingly naïve voters only exist in the Republican Party, you are wrong, wrong, wrong.
But the other big takeaway and growing realization is that the ballot may not be enough to remove Trump. Trump is not just a politician, he’s the leader of a movement that represents all the worst aspects of America, and his tribe is fanatically loyal and getting only more so. If we think of Trump only as a politician, we will never be free of him.
As Trump noted the night before the election, when asked about the possibility of the Democrats winning the House: “I don’t care. They can do whatever they want and I can do whatever I want.”
And he proved this morning, with his takeover of the Justice Department, that he is committed to not only obstructing justice but obliterating it.